Moist Caramel Cake Recipe (2024)

This is hands down the best caramel cake I’ve ever had! It consists of super moist vanilla brown sugar cake layers, topped with a luscious and deep flavored caramel frosting that isn’t sickly sweet. This is a Southern style caramel cake recipe – a caramel lovers DREAM cake!

Why You’ll Love This Caramel Cake

My number one problem when it comes to caramel cakes, is that they’re usually way too sweet! What I love about this recipe (and what I think you’ll love!) is that the caramel isn’t overly sweet, and doesn’t compromise on caramel flavor AT ALL!

Caramel Frosting

The caramel frosting used for this recipe is the type used in Southern caramel cake recipes, which involves cooking down a combination of butter, sugar and evaporated milk, until you reach a thick, golden brown caramel sauce. You then add in cream to thin it out so you can use it as a frosting.

The process does take a bit of time (the total time on average is about an hour), but TRUST ME it is so worth it. I tried different types of caramel icing when developing this recipe, and this Southern style was by far the winner! It has a complex caramel flavor without being sickly sweet.

Cake Layers

This recipe uses vanilla brown sugar cake layers as the base. It’s a super moist, rich and buttery yellow cake, similar to my vanilla cake recipe, but with even more buttery flavour. The addition of brown sugar gives the cake a subtle caramel flavour (similar to my coffee cake and spice cake recipe) without it being overpowering – which really allows the frosting to shine!

For this recipe I used sour cream to give the cake layers a super tender crumb! You can substitute the sour cream with plain, unsweetened yoghurt or buttermilk if you can’t easily find it.

How to Make Caramel Cake

Caramel Cake Layers

First is the cake batter. Begin by Preheating your oven to 160 °C (320°F)with the fan on and grease or line (with parchment paper) two 8 inch cake pans (I use myhomemade cake release). If your oven doesn’t have a fan option, then you will need to increase the baking temperature to 175°C/350°F.

Sift together all purpose flour, cornstarch, baking powder and salt. Using a whisk or fork, mix until well combined. Set aside for now.

In a large mixing bowl combine butter, vegetable oil, white sugar and brown sugar. Using an electric mixer on a medium speed, cream together for 2 minutes until light and creamy.

Add in eggs one by one, mixing well in between each addition (about 10-15 seconds between eggs).

Next add in sour cream and vanilla and mix until well combined. Now set your mixer aside as the remainder of the batter will be finished by hand.

Finish off by adding in half of your premixed flour mixture to your wet ingredients, and gently fold it in with a spatula until just combined. Then add in the milk, and fold it in until just combined. Lastly, add in the remaining dry ingredients and gently fold it into the mixture until just combined. Do not overmix.

Distribute the batter evenly into the two 8 inch cake tins, and bake for 28- 30 minutes or until a toothpick comes out clean.

Once baked, allow the cake layers to cool in the cake tins for about 15-20 minutes, and then turn them out onto a wire rack to completely cool before frosting with the caramel.

Caramel Cake Frosting

Place a large saucepan over a medium heat and add in butter, sugar, evaporated milk and salt. Allow everything to melt together and come to a simmer, stirring continuously. Once simmering, turn the heat down to a low-medium heat.

Allow the caramel to thicken up slowly for about an hour, stirring every few minutes to make sure the caramel isn’t burning. Be sure to check on it more frequently once it starts to thicken up as this is when it is more prone to burning. Once it is thick (see video for visual), and a deep golden brown colour, add in the cream and vanilla. Stir until the caramle is smooth, and then immediately pour it into a heat proof dish.

Allow the caramel to cool for about 25 minutes before frosting the cake. You still want the caramel to be slightly warm and runny when frosting the cake, as it sets up quickly once you come to using it.

Assembly

Once cakes are cooled, level the tops with a serrated knife so that the cake layers are flat.

Place the first cake layer onto your cake stand/serving platter and place a generous amount of the caramel frosting on top and smooth it out with an offset spatula or knife.

Place your next cake layer on top and cover the top and sides with more caramel frosting. Once the caramel starts to set up, you will notice it become shiny. You can run an offset spatula or knife gently on top of the shiny caramel and this will make everything super smooth! Decorate as you wish and enjoy!

Commonly Asked Questions

How do you store caramel cake?

This caramel cake can be left out at room temperature in an airtight container for a few days. After that it should be refrigerated and will last up to a week.

What do I do if my caramel is too thin?

If your caramel frosing is too thin and not setting up when you come to frosting the cake, it most likely just needs time to cool down further and firm up a bit more. Let it cool for another 20 minutes or so and this should do the trick. If it’s still not setting up when frosting the cake layers, then it means that you need to reduce the caramel over a stove top further.

What is my caramel too thick?

If the caramel is too thick, it’s most likely due to the caramel cooling down a bit too much before using it to frost the cake. Remember you still want the caramel to be slightly warm and runny when it comes to frosting the cake. If it’s too thick, simply heat up the caramel slightly, or you can also mix in a little more cream to thin it out.

Why is my caramel very gummy and chewy once set?

If the caramel is very hard to eat, it means the caramel was overheated when the frosting was being made. Be sure to only cook the caramel until it thickens in consistency (see video for visual demonstration), and take it off the heat once the cream is mixed in.